Attack on Titan Season 3 Episode 5: Reply
Manga chapter 59-60
Canon/HIGH
OSHIMETER
9.6
12 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
OSHIMETER
9.6
12 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
QUICK TAKES
konami
VerifiedThis episode is Erwin's chess mastery, mindgames, and strategies.
ffffaiz
VerifiedHow they organized such coup is just perfect. Creating necessary chaos to see what the lords would do, putting themselves over their people. Its just a chefs kiss the way they handle it.
stevenodhiambo442
VerifiedBut here's the thing Erwin wasn't actually trying to convince them. He was stalling. Because he knew what was coming.
alexvvc
VerifiedThis episode feels like the calm before the storm. It makes me even more curious about what’s coming next and what secrets are still waiting to unfold. Every scene builds anticipation, and honestly, not a single episode of this anime ever feels boring.
alrickalmight
VerifiedWhat would be Eren's fate? The scout regiment are dealing with alot on their hands, and they still have to prioritise saving Eren at all cost. It is sad, living in such a wicked world like that.
hopedotgg
VerifiedEpisode 5 brings political chaos and surprises that throw the Scouts’ plans off balance, highlighting how unpredictable the fight for humanity’s future really is.
charliereviews
VerifiedThe plan to take down the corrupt officials was clever and well-executed. I felt so satisfied seeing it succeed. I was also surprised by Zachary’s character, and the cliffhanger at the end has me eager for the next episode
jimmytole1262
Erwin's plan is pretty genius, it's crazy how they pulled it off. The way they created chaos to test the lords is clever. Definitely watch this one, it's got some surprising moments
zojoman
This is a certified 10 out of 10 for political drama. Erwin Smith logic is unmatched and seeing his gamble pay off is a massive flex. The dialogue is sharp and the stakes are life or death.
animeroshi
This episode is a political Titan, no giants needed. Erwin’s logic cornered the nobles, then Pyxis and Zachary sprung the cleanest coup in the series. The “breach” bluff exposes their greed fast. Freedom tastes sweet… until we cut to Eren chained underground.
yonahime
It never fails to amaze me how intuitive and intelligent Erwin Smith is. His gamble was risky, but they still succeeded—despite others having different perspectives. Mind blown! More mysteries are starting to unfold, leaving you in anticipation.
sheila_jade
EPISODE CONTEXT
Picking up directly from the fallout of 'Trust,' where the Scout Regiment's allegiance came under scrutiny, 'Reply' deepens the season's focus on internal power struggles and the cost of challenging entrenched authority. As the fifth of twelve episodes, it marks the transition point where political maneuvering reaches its peak before the season pivots toward darker revelations about the royal family in the following episode, 'Sin.' This is the fulcrum between setup and payoff for the entire first half of Season 3.
QUICK TAKES
konami
VerifiedThis episode is Erwin's chess mastery, mindgames, and strategies.
ffffaiz
VerifiedHow they organized such coup is just perfect. Creating necessary chaos to see what the lords would do, putting themselves over their people. Its just a chefs kiss the way they handle it.
stevenodhiambo442
VerifiedBut here's the thing Erwin wasn't actually trying to convince them. He was stalling. Because he knew what was coming.
alexvvc
VerifiedThis episode feels like the calm before the storm. It makes me even more curious about what’s coming next and what secrets are still waiting to unfold. Every scene builds anticipation, and honestly, not a single episode of this anime ever feels boring.
alrickalmight
VerifiedWhat would be Eren's fate? The scout regiment are dealing with alot on their hands, and they still have to prioritise saving Eren at all cost. It is sad, living in such a wicked world like that.
hopedotgg
VerifiedEpisode 5 brings political chaos and surprises that throw the Scouts’ plans off balance, highlighting how unpredictable the fight for humanity’s future really is.
charliereviews
VerifiedThe plan to take down the corrupt officials was clever and well-executed. I felt so satisfied seeing it succeed. I was also surprised by Zachary’s character, and the cliffhanger at the end has me eager for the next episode
jimmytole1262
Erwin's plan is pretty genius, it's crazy how they pulled it off. The way they created chaos to test the lords is clever. Definitely watch this one, it's got some surprising moments
zojoman
This is a certified 10 out of 10 for political drama. Erwin Smith logic is unmatched and seeing his gamble pay off is a massive flex. The dialogue is sharp and the stakes are life or death.
animeroshi
This episode is a political Titan, no giants needed. Erwin’s logic cornered the nobles, then Pyxis and Zachary sprung the cleanest coup in the series. The “breach” bluff exposes their greed fast. Freedom tastes sweet… until we cut to Eren chained underground.
yonahime
It never fails to amaze me how intuitive and intelligent Erwin Smith is. His gamble was risky, but they still succeeded—despite others having different perspectives. Mind blown! More mysteries are starting to unfold, leaving you in anticipation.
sheila_jade
©諫山創・講談社／「進撃の巨人」製作委員会
AnimeOshi.com refers to anime titles, character names, logos, and other trademarked or copyrighted materials to identify and describe the works being reviewed, discussed, ranked or otherwise referenced on this site. This usage is believed to be nominative fair use or non-infringing and is not intended to imply any affiliation with the respective rights holders.
All trademarks and copyrights remain the property of their owners. If you are a rights holder and have concerns about any content on this site, please contact us at legal@animeoshi.com