One Piece Episode 384: Brook's Great Struggle! Is the Path to Becoming a True Comrade Rigorous?
Filler/LOW
OSHIMETER
9.6
63 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
LIVE · THE WEEKLY VERDICT
One Piece Episode 384: Brook's Great Struggle! Is the Path to Becoming a True Comrade Rigorous?
Filler/LOW
OSHIMETER
9.6
63 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
QUICK TAKES
n
Brook trying so hard to help and failing at every turn is equal parts funny and sad but it makes sense after he spent fifty years alone and just wants to be useful
itzzeom
Filler gets a bad name but this episode proves we need more downtime with the Straw Hats because the way Brook feels like an intruder is so relatable
monk_kass
I loved seeing everyone doing their own thing on the ship and Brook failing at helping Zoro or Sanji was funny but also super sad once you think about why he is doing it
eternatus_315
Brook, truly a part of the Straw Hats and just hanging out on the Sunny, felt so incredibly right to me. I actually got a little misty-eyed seeing him finally find a home after all those decades of silence; it made me wonder how much he must cherish these simple moments.
casca_the_commander_190
Brook trying so hard to help out really got to me because he was alone for way too long and just wants to be part of the group and the ending with him playing Bink's Brew was so sweet
haruka_tenoh
I never thought a filler episode would make me this emotional but Brook trying to wash dishes for Sanji and failing just felt so heavy. He spent fifty years on a ghost ship alone so he has no clue how to actually live with people anymore. Seeing him take that nap at the end while Bink’s Brew played made my day
emerald
Robin talking to Brook is exactly what he needed and seeing them relate over being outsiders made that whole scene feel so special
chopper_champion_38
Zoro getting annoyed during his workout because of Brook was classic. It is great to see the skeleton finally realizing he does not have to earn his keep to be a Straw Hat
megurine_marvel_496
Most filler is a skip but this one actually matters for Brook's character development. His fear of being a burden is so relatable after everything he went through in the Florian Triangle
sophia_ascart_167
The way Brook watches everyone from a distance at the start really highlights his isolation, and it makes the ending much more rewarding. This was some of the best character work for the skeleton guy
toby_lvl22
When Brook completely freaked out over spilling tea on Nami's map, I couldn't help but crack up, even while feeling a twinge of sadness for him. It really shows me how deeply those fifty lonely years still weigh on him, making him so anxious about keeping his new family happy and safe.
kittan_bachika_188
Brook's attempts to "help" Zoro with his training were a riot, but then it got me really feeling for him when he started questioning his worth to the crew. I know that feeling of being an outsider, and it was so comforting to see Robin, who understands that struggle better than anyone, quietly reassure him that he's absolutely family.
rangiku_rider
I felt a bit bad for Brook when he started doubting his place on the ship after being alone in the dark for so long. He just needs to realize the crew already loves him
rei_ayanami
You can tell Brook is just desperate to prove he belongs by how much he overdoes the chores. The scene where he ruins the tea was so hard to watch because he looked so defeated
tellu
Brook trying so hard to be useful only to mess up Sanji's food was actually kind of sad. He just wants to belong and it shows
weebirez
It is nice to see Nami actually working on her maps for once instead of just shouting orders. These quiet moments on the ship are why this filler is better than most canon episodes
nanami_nexus
Robin talking to Brook on the deck was easily the highlight. She is the only one who really gets what it feels like to be an outsider waiting for the axe to drop
shinobu_sting_130
Luffy just accepting Brook without any questions is such a classic captain move and it really helped settle his nerves about being part of the group
xerneas_311
Those quiet moments, like Zoro completely passed out on deck with Sanji cooking nearby, really hit me different than the big fights do. I actually find myself caring more about their bonds when they're just being themselves, a found family rather than a fighting unit, and it's what makes me so invested in their journey. It's the little things that show me how much they truly mean to each other.
reshiram_310
I usually skip filler episodes but I am so glad I stayed for this one because seeing the crew just hanging out on the Sunny is exactly what the show needs more of. Brook being so desperate to prove his worth after fifty years of silence broke my heart, and Robin was the perfect person to tell him to just relax
EPISODE CONTEXT
Positioned after the Spa Island filler arc, this episode functions as a transitional breather before the Straw Hats head toward their next major destination on the Grand Line. It's a filler installment dedicated to fleshing out Brook's dynamic with the crew following his official recruitment during Thriller Bark. No plot threads are advanced here, so viewers can safely skip it without missing story beats, though it offers additional Brook characterization for fans invested in his integration arc.
QUICK TAKES
n
Brook trying so hard to help and failing at every turn is equal parts funny and sad but it makes sense after he spent fifty years alone and just wants to be useful
itzzeom
Filler gets a bad name but this episode proves we need more downtime with the Straw Hats because the way Brook feels like an intruder is so relatable
monk_kass
I loved seeing everyone doing their own thing on the ship and Brook failing at helping Zoro or Sanji was funny but also super sad once you think about why he is doing it
eternatus_315
Brook, truly a part of the Straw Hats and just hanging out on the Sunny, felt so incredibly right to me. I actually got a little misty-eyed seeing him finally find a home after all those decades of silence; it made me wonder how much he must cherish these simple moments.
casca_the_commander_190
Brook trying so hard to help out really got to me because he was alone for way too long and just wants to be part of the group and the ending with him playing Bink's Brew was so sweet
haruka_tenoh
I never thought a filler episode would make me this emotional but Brook trying to wash dishes for Sanji and failing just felt so heavy. He spent fifty years on a ghost ship alone so he has no clue how to actually live with people anymore. Seeing him take that nap at the end while Bink’s Brew played made my day
emerald
Robin talking to Brook is exactly what he needed and seeing them relate over being outsiders made that whole scene feel so special
chopper_champion_38
Zoro getting annoyed during his workout because of Brook was classic. It is great to see the skeleton finally realizing he does not have to earn his keep to be a Straw Hat
megurine_marvel_496
Most filler is a skip but this one actually matters for Brook's character development. His fear of being a burden is so relatable after everything he went through in the Florian Triangle
sophia_ascart_167
The way Brook watches everyone from a distance at the start really highlights his isolation, and it makes the ending much more rewarding. This was some of the best character work for the skeleton guy
toby_lvl22
When Brook completely freaked out over spilling tea on Nami's map, I couldn't help but crack up, even while feeling a twinge of sadness for him. It really shows me how deeply those fifty lonely years still weigh on him, making him so anxious about keeping his new family happy and safe.
kittan_bachika_188
Brook's attempts to "help" Zoro with his training were a riot, but then it got me really feeling for him when he started questioning his worth to the crew. I know that feeling of being an outsider, and it was so comforting to see Robin, who understands that struggle better than anyone, quietly reassure him that he's absolutely family.
rangiku_rider
I felt a bit bad for Brook when he started doubting his place on the ship after being alone in the dark for so long. He just needs to realize the crew already loves him
rei_ayanami
You can tell Brook is just desperate to prove he belongs by how much he overdoes the chores. The scene where he ruins the tea was so hard to watch because he looked so defeated
tellu
Brook trying so hard to be useful only to mess up Sanji's food was actually kind of sad. He just wants to belong and it shows
weebirez
It is nice to see Nami actually working on her maps for once instead of just shouting orders. These quiet moments on the ship are why this filler is better than most canon episodes
nanami_nexus
Robin talking to Brook on the deck was easily the highlight. She is the only one who really gets what it feels like to be an outsider waiting for the axe to drop
shinobu_sting_130
Luffy just accepting Brook without any questions is such a classic captain move and it really helped settle his nerves about being part of the group
xerneas_311
Those quiet moments, like Zoro completely passed out on deck with Sanji cooking nearby, really hit me different than the big fights do. I actually find myself caring more about their bonds when they're just being themselves, a found family rather than a fighting unit, and it's what makes me so invested in their journey. It's the little things that show me how much they truly mean to each other.
reshiram_310
I usually skip filler episodes but I am so glad I stayed for this one because seeing the crew just hanging out on the Sunny is exactly what the show needs more of. Brook being so desperate to prove his worth after fifty years of silence broke my heart, and Robin was the perfect person to tell him to just relax
LIVE · THE WEEKLY VERDICT
©東映・東映アニメーション・集英社・フジテレビ・バンダイ ©尾田栄一郎／集英社・フジテレビ・東映アニメーション
AnimeOshi.com refers to anime titles, character names, logos, and other trademarked or copyrighted materials to identify and describe the works being reviewed, discussed, ranked or otherwise referenced on this site. This usage is believed to be nominative fair use or non-infringing and is not intended to imply any affiliation with the respective rights holders.
All trademarks and copyrights remain the property of their owners. If you are a rights holder and have concerns about any content on this site, please contact us at legal@animeoshi.com